Are Classroom Computers Hindering Education?
Technology
is rapidly spreading and growing, and is quickly becoming a go-to source for
knowledge and education, but are we really learning as much as we think we are?
High-school teacher Michael Zwaagstra argues that young children in earlier
grades learning how to use computers are wasting the chance to learn about more
vital subjects such as math and English. However, computers are now the future,
and it could be seen as vital that children learn to navigate one. Either way,
computers may change a child’s education for better or worse.
Some
people might state that time is money, and the same could be said for
education. Time is indeed education, and computer education cuts in to that
precious time for younger grades. Zwaagstra questioned the logic behind
teaching computer software to younger grades, as said hardware will eventually
become outdated. Teachers only have so much time to educate with, and other,
more beneficial skills could be leaned rather than computer education. On top
of the time dilemma, computers can hinder skills such as spelling and writing, as
computers will check your spelling for you, preventing you from honing literary
skills. Not only that, but computers cost money, and that money could have went
to hiring more teachers, which would have decreased class sizes and been more
beneficial for both teachers and students alike. Overall, computers cut into
both time and a child’s early education.
However,
computers can open up a new world of education for students. Learning how to
use a computer and the software which corresponds with it can be a beneficial
skill for a child’s life. Also, a computer with access to the internet can give
a child a wealth of resources to work and learn with, helping the child grow.
Learning how to use a computer could also help make a teacher’s job easier, as
children could hand in their assignments online, allowing teachers to view all
of their student’s homework in one place and take it anywhere with them. Computers
can also provide career opportunities, and if kids find an interest early on in
computers through school, they may find their own career path early on. To
conclude, computers make time in the classroom easier and may provide a future
for many students.
Contradictory
to this, in my opinion, I believe that Zwaagstra is correct in arguing that
students are losing vital education time by learning about computers. I believe
students in early grades should not be learning about technology that they will
eventually learn later in their life. This technology will continue to grow,
and students will learn what they need to when the time is right. Funds meant
for schooling should be going to more beneficial things, rather than having
children learn about software soon to become obsolete. Computers may open the
door for some, but in the end, the educational time wasted on them hurts all.
I agree completely with your opinion in that learning about computers is a waste of time at a young age and would distract children. However I think that being technologically illiterate at a later age is just as bad if not worse. While it is not good to teach too early it is far worse to not learn at all. I believe it comes down to the time which is chosen to teach students about technology that matters most.
ReplyDelete